How to Choose First Butt Plug

How to Choose First Butt Plug

So many of us grow up hearing a thousand warnings about anal pleasure but absolutely zero guidance on how it actually works or how to choose a safe sex toy. Then one day, curiosity hits. Maybe it happens while scrolling social media, maybe your friend mentions it playfully, or maybe you are simply exploring your own pleasure.

Whatever the reason, choosing a beginner friendly butt plug sex toy in India can feel like a mix of excitement, confusion, and nervous giggles. And feeling this way about trying an adult toy for the first time is completely normal.

The truth is that anal play is not taboo anymore, especially when it comes to modern sex toys for women and men in India. People are exploring beginner butt plugs and other anal plugs because they can make solo sessions more satisfying, enhance partnered intimacy, and build a deeper understanding of your own pleasure. More and more people are also discovering how easy it is to shop discreetly for adult toys in India. But there is one golden rule. 

Choosing the best butt plugs for beginners from our list of top but plugs truly matters. Your comfort, safety, and pleasure depend entirely on picking a butt plug that suits your experience level, your body, and your goals.

 That is why this guide on how to choose your first butt plug adult toy and the next one you graduate to is important.

Understanding the Basics Before You Begin

Before we jump into product recommendations, let us clear up a few common doubts. These anal plugs and butt plug sex toys are designed to stay in place because of their shape, and they absolutely must have a flared base so they do not slip in too far. They are meant for slow, intentional insertion and should never cause sharp pain. Your body needs lubrication because the anus does not self lubricate, and beginners should always start small, go slow, and listen to their body.

This is why the right size, material, and shape make such a big difference. Silicone plugs are generally the safest and most comfortable because they are body safe and flexible. Metal plugs add weight and intensity. Vibrating butt plug toys can create more stimulation, but they are better once you have some practice. For beginners, a small, smooth, tapered plug is the perfect starting point.

Best Anal Butt Plugs in India

If this is your first time choosing a butt plug sex toy, you deserve something that makes the experience simple, soothing, and enjoyable.

 1. A great starting point is the Anal Fantasy Collection Beginners Fantasy Kit. This kit gives you a gentle way to explore, starting with smaller sizes and slowly moving up when your body feels ready. The anal plugs in this set are smooth, lightweight, and shaped in a way that sits comfortably once inserted. Having multiple sizes in one kit takes away the fear of choosing the wrong plug and gives you the chance to learn at your own pace.

Anal Fantasy Beginner&

2. Another beginner friendly butt plug option is the Nexus Anal Beginner Kit. This set is ideal for someone who wants to train their body gradually. The progression feels natural, and the silicone texture is perfect for comfort. For many beginners browsing women sex toys and couples’ adult toys in India, this kind of kit is especially helpful if you see anal exploration as a long term pleasure journey rather than a one time experiment.

Nexus Anal Beginner Kit-IMbesharam.com

3. If you want a single, simple, smooth plug to begin with, the Rocks Off Smooth Plug. offers a classic shape that glides in easily and stays secure. It is the type of plug that helps your body understand what a plug should feel like without overwhelming sensations and fits well into any basic sex toy collection.

Rocks Off Petite Sensations Smooth Butt Plug-IMbesharam.com

Once your body feels familiar with the feeling of a plug, you may want to explore more intense sensations. This is when shape, weight, and vibration become interesting options, especially if you are curious about upgrading from simple anal plugs to a vibrating butt plug.

4. If prostate stimulation is calling your name, the Rocks Off Quest Prostate Massager is a smart choice for an anal plug style massager.

 The curved design is beginner friendly but still delivers targeted pleasure that can feel new and deeply satisfying. Prostate play can create powerful orgasms for many penis owners, and using a dedicated sex toy like this massager makes all the difference.

Rocks Off Quest Prostate Massager-IMbesharam.com

5. If you want something aesthetically gorgeous and slightly weightier, the Cheeky Charms Gunmetal Heart Butt Plug is a beautiful metal plug that feels luxurious and sensual.

 The added weight enhances fullness and sensation, making it perfect once you are no longer a complete beginner and ready to explore more advanced adult toys in India.

Viben Cheeky Charms Gunmetal Heart Butt Plug-IMbesharam.com

6. For couples or queer cuties looking to explore together, the Amorelie Queer Kings Pleasure Box is a curated box full of pleasure essentials that encourage playful experimentation and shared intimacy. It is a lovely step up for partners exploring anal play with trust and excitement, and it pairs beautifully with other sex toys for women, men, and non-binary folks who enjoy variety.

Amorelie Queer Kings Premium Pleasure Box-IMbesharam.com

The Importance of Lube and Relaxation Your Best Friends in Anal Play

If you are exploring butt plugs without lubrication, your body will not enjoy the experience. Anal tissue needs moisture to relax, open up, and stay comfortable, whether you are using a simple plug or a vibrating butt plug sex toy.

1. A must have partner is EasyGlide Anal Water Based Lubricant. This lube is specifically designed for anal play and helps reduce friction, making insertion smoother and easing your body into new sensations.

Hand holding EasyGlide anal lubricant 150ml in modern bathroom setting for lifestyle product display

2. If you feel nervous or tense, Secret Play Relax Anal Gel can help by creating a gentle relaxation effect around the anal muscles. It is not a numbing gel but a calming one, which is exactly what beginners need for safe and comfortable play with any anal plugs or butt plug sex toys.

Secret Play Relax! Anal Gel-IMbesharam.com

How to Begin Insert? 

When you start using a butt plug as a beginner, make sure you feel relaxed and unhurried. Use plenty of lube on both the plug and the entrance. Begin with the tip and breathe out as you gently guide it in. Your body should feel invited, not forced. A small stretching sensation is normal. Sharp discomfort is not. Once the plug is in, give your body a moment to adjust. Move around. Notice how it feels. And if you ever feel like removing it, simply exhale and slide it out slowly.

Cleaning is important too. Wash your butt plug sex toy with warm water and toy safe cleaner before and after use. Store it in a clean space so your next session is always ready to go.

Choosing a butt plug should feel exciting, not intimidating. When you pick the right size, shape, and material, your body responds with ease and pleasure. With tools like beginner friendly kits, prostate massagers, aesthetic metal plugs, and supportive lubricants, your journey with adult toy exploration becomes smoother and far more enjoyable.

Anal play is not about being bold. It is about knowing your body and giving yourself permission to explore. So whether this is your first plug or your next one, remember that safety, comfort, and curiosity lead to the best experiences with sex toys for women, men, and anyone curious about anal plugs in India.

Sign UP

FOR OUR ONCE A MONTH EMAILS

they have scoops, deals and more